Are Job Offer Letters Legally Required?

No, job offer letters are not legally required.

It's customary for employers to extend a verbal job offer followed by a formal written letter. These letters typically include details like the start date, compensation, benefits, employment status, and conditions such as background checks or drug screenings. They give new hires a chance to review the details before moving forward with the onboarding process. But while they’re common, are they necessary?

Legal Requirements for Offer Letters

There is no legal obligation to provide a job offer letter. However, formal offer letters can help set clear expectations for new hires. But be cautious—if not carefully worded, these letters can unintentionally bind employers to promises.

A notable example is the TSR Consulting Services, Inc. v. Larry Steinhouse case. Here, an offer letter with specific guarantees about salary and commissions was found to be a binding contract. This resulted in a substantial settlement for the employee. The Letter explicitly stated: 

For the first twelve months of your employment, through May 31, 1998, your compensation will consist of a base salary, which if annualized would be $120,000. In addition, you will receive a guaranteed non-recoverable draw of $10,000 against commissions for this same period. Also, as you requested an additional recoverable draw of $20,000 against commissions can be provided. The objectives for the additional incentive/compensation commissions are outlined in schedule A. For the second year of your employment, you will receive a guaranteed recoverable draw of $120,000 against commissions.

Due to the wording of the offer letter, which includes the word “guaranteed” as well as the specified term for payment, the ruling found the offer letter to be a binding contract. This meant that TSR in fact owed Steinhouse what was listed in the contract. This ultimately amounted to nearly a quarter of a million dollars. In the end, TSR settled the case without going to court. An expensive mistake. 

The lesson? Careless wording can lead to costly legal commitments.

Risks of Not Sending an Offer Letter

Employers are not at legal risk for choosing not to send an offer letter. In fact, the real risk lies in sending one hastily. Poorly crafted offer letters can lead to legal troubles if promises made in the letter aren’t met.

Offer Letters vs. Employment Contracts

Offer letters and employment contracts serve different purposes. An offer letter extends a job offer simply and informally. In contrast, an employment contract is a detailed, legally binding agreement. It outlines conditions for termination, salary details, and severance packages. While offer letters can become binding if poorly worded, employment contracts are designed to be comprehensive and binding from the start. 

Employment contracts are not legally required either but are highly recommended for clear, binding agreements. They also help clearly define employment relationships. Technically, you can use both an offer letter and an employment contract, but it’s best to keep offer letters simple to minimize risk.

Best Practices for Employment Contracts

If your organization chooses to use employment contracts, follow these best practices to ensure clarity and compliance:

• Use a Template: Standardize your contracts with templates reviewed by HR to avoid legal disputes. Store signed contracts in your HRIS.
• Avoid Offer Letters: To minimize risk, focus on employment contracts. If you do use offer letters, have them reviewed by an attorney.
• Make Job Offers Verbally: Start with a verbal offer. Follow this with a formal employment contract upon acceptance to reduce the risks associated with written offer letters.

By managing job offers and documentation carefully, employers can avoid unnecessary risks and ensure a smooth hiring process.

Additional Resources

You can stay informed, educated, and up to date with important HR topics using BerniePortal’s comprehensive resources:

• BernieU—free online HR courses, approved for SHRM and HRCI recertification credit
• BerniePortal Blog—a one-stop shop for HR industry news
• HR Glossary—featuring the most common HR terms, acronyms, and compliance
• Resource Library—essential guides covering a comprehensive list of HR topics
• HR Party of One—our popular YouTube series and podcast, covering emerging HR trends and enduring HR topics
• Community—the HR Party of One Community forum, a place devoted to HR professionals to ask questions, learn more, and help others